Why Does Sparkling Water Taste Bad

Why Does Sparkling Water Taste Bad? 5 Surprising Reasons

7 min read

Many people often wonder, ‘Why does sparkling water taste bad?’ This question arises due to sparkling water’s unique taste that doesn’t appeal to everyone. Here, we will explore why this happens and how you can improve the taste using a home soda maker.

The Science Behind the Taste

The main reason why sparkling water might not be palatable to some is due to the carbonation process it undergoes.

Carbon dioxide gas dissolves in water under pressure and forms carbonic acid. This reaction gives sparkling water its characteristic fizz but also results in a slightly sour taste and a tingling sensation.

To further understand ‘why does sparkling water taste bad’ to some, it’s important to note that compared to sweetened beverages, unsweetened sparkling water may seem bland or bitter, especially if one is not accustomed to the taste.

Why Does Sparkling Water Taste Bad?

  1. Carbonation: The process of carbonation creates carbonic acid, which can give sparkling water a slight tart or sour flavor that some people find off-putting.
  2. Mineral Content: Some brands of sparkling water contain added minerals like sodium, calcium, and magnesium. Depending on your taste preferences, these minerals might make the water taste salty or metallic.
  3. Lack of Sweetness: If you’re used to drinking sweet beverages, the absence of sugar in sparkling water might make it taste bland or even bitter to you.
  4. Temperature: Interestingly, the temperature at which you drink sparkling water can affect its taste. Cold sparkling water tends to taste less bitter than room temperature sparkling water.
  5. Individual Taste Buds: Everyone’s taste buds are different. What one person finds refreshing, another might find unpleasant. If you don’t like the taste of sparkling water, it might simply be that your taste buds prefer other flavors.

What Does Sparkling Water Taste Like?

The taste of sparkling water can vary depending on its source and the process used to carbonate it.

Generally, it has a clean and crisp taste with a hint of minerality.

The carbonation process infuses the water with bubbles, creating a fizzy sensation that is both refreshing and invigorating.

However, the carbonation also forms carbonic acid, giving sparkling water a slightly acidic or sour taste.

This might be perceived as a kind of bitterness or tartness, which some people find unappealing, while others enjoy it for its refreshing quality.

In addition, if minerals like sodium, calcium, and magnesium are present in the water (as is the case with some natural mineral waters), they can contribute additional flavors. Some people describe this as a “salty” or “earthy” taste.

Why Does Carbonated Water Taste Sour?

The sour taste in carbonated water comes from the carbonation process it undergoes.

When carbon dioxide (CO2) is dissolved in water, it forms a weak acid called carbonic acid.

This acidification of the water results in a slightly sour or tart flavor.

Additionally, this reaction stimulates an enzyme in our taste buds that converts the carbonic acid into protons and bicarbonate.

These protons signal to our brain a sour taste. So while carbon dioxide itself is odorless and flavorless, once it’s introduced into the water and interacts with our taste buds, it produces a sour taste.

It’s worth noting that the level of sourness can vary depending on the amount of carbonation. More heavily carbonated waters will have a stronger sour taste than lightly carbonated ones.

Why Does Carbonated Water Taste Salty?

The salty taste in carbonated water can come from the minerals present in the water.

Some sparkling water brands contain added minerals like sodium, giving the water a slightly salty taste. However, not all carbonated waters have this salty taste.

Another reason some people might perceive a salty taste is due to the carbonation process.

When carbon dioxide is dissolved in water, it forms carbonic acid, which changes the water’s flavor profile.

While this doesn’t technically make the water salty, the change in taste might be interpreted as saltiness by some people’s palates.

Lastly, taste perception can vary greatly among individuals. Some people might associate carbonic acid’s sharp, tangy taste with saltiness, while others might perceive it as more sour or bitter.

The best tasting sparkling waters in the world as of 2023

Based on various sources and reviews, some of the best tasting sparkling waters in the world as of 2023 include:

San Pellegrino praised for its gentle bubbles and subtle mineral taste, and Radenska, which is a top choice for mineral water.

For flavored sparkling water, Spindrift is highly recommended. It’s known for its refreshing taste as it uses real fruit juice for flavoring.

Other popular brands include La Croix, Bubly, and Polar, each offering a variety of unique flavors.

Topo Chico is also a favorite among sparkling water enthusiasts. It’s particularly loved for its strong carbonation and crisp taste.

Sanzo and Tranquini offer some of the best flavored sparkling waters, with a range of unique and refreshing flavors.

Lastly, brands like Voss and Glacéau Smartwater Sparkling are favored for their clean and crisp taste.

However, everyone’s taste is different, so it’s worth trying a few to see which one you prefer.

Several methods to make sparkling water at home:

  1. Using a Soda Siphon or Seltzer Bottle involves filling a siphon with water and a CO2 cartridge. The pressurized gas carbonates the water. It’s a quick and relatively inexpensive method.
  2. Using a Soda Maker or Sparkling Water Maker: These machines carbonate water by injecting CO2 from a pressurized cylinder. Brands like SodaStream are popular choices for this method.
  3. DIY Carbonation Method: This involves using yeast and sugar to produce CO2 naturally. The fermentation process creates bubbles, similar to how champagne is made.

As for which method makes sparkling water taste better, it largely depends on personal preference. However, using a soda maker or sparkling water maker often provides the most control over the level of carbonation, allowing you to adjust the fizziness to your liking. Plus, many of these machines also allow for flavor additions, enabling you to enhance the taste further.

Remember, for the best-tasting sparkling water, start with high-quality water that tastes good to you when still. Cold water tends to hold carbonation better, so chilling the water beforehand can also improve the result.

Enhancing the Taste with a Home Soda Maker

One way to tackle the issue of ‘why does sparkling water taste bad’ is by using a home soda maker. This handy device allows you to control the level of carbonation in your water, thereby enabling you to adjust the taste according to your preference.

Benefits and Ease of Use of a Home Sode Maker

A home soda maker is a cost-effective and convenient solution for those who love sparkling water but find its taste unappealing.

With this device, you can create your own sparkling water at home, adjusting the carbonation levels until you find your perfect balance.

Adjusting the carbonation levels can help fix the sparkling water tasting issue because the carbonation level directly influences the water’s taste.

Carbonation adds bubbles to the water but also changes the water’s chemistry, creating carbonic acid.

This acid imparts a slightly sour taste and creates a tingling sensation in the mouth, which some people find unpleasant.

By controlling the carbonation level, you can manage how much carbonic acid is formed, thereby adjusting the sourness and fizziness of the sparkling water to your personal taste preference.

Less carbonation will make the water taste more like still water, while more carbonation will enhance the fizzy sensation and sour taste.

So, if you find the taste of commercially available sparkling water off-putting, a home soda maker that allows you to adjust carbonation levels could be the solution.

You can experiment with different levels of fizz until you find the perfect balance that suits your palate.

Using a home soda maker is quite simple.

You need to fill the provided bottle with tap or filtered water, attach it to the machine, and press the carbonating button until you reach your desired fizziness level.

Flavoring Your Sparkling Water

Another way to combat the question of ‘why does sparkling water taste bad’ is by adding flavors. Most home soda makers come with a range of flavors that you can add to your homemade sparkling water. From fruity flavors like lemon-lime and orange to more exotic ones like raspberry and ginger, there are plenty of options to explore.

Our favorites are:

  • Lemon-Lime: This classic flavor is refreshing and tangy, perfect for a hot day.
  • Cola: A popular choice that tastes similar to traditional soda drinks.
  • Ginger Ale: For those who prefer a bit of spice in their drink.
  • Orange: Bright and citrusy, this flavor is a favorite among many.
  • Raspberry: Offers a sweet yet tart taste.
  • Root Beer: Ideal for those who love this classic soda flavor.
  • Grapefruit: For a tangy and slightly bitter flavor profile.

Here are some of the best sparkling water flavor brands:

  • SodaStream: One of the most popular brands, they offer a wide range of flavors from classic Cola to exotic Fruit Drops.
  • DrinkMate: Known for its high-quality carbonation system, they also have a variety of flavors available.
  • KitchenAid: While mostly known for their kitchen appliances, their soda syrups are also well-reviewed.
  • Flavorstation: Offers a good selection of flavors, including both classic and unique options.
  • Aarke: While they don’t manufacture their own flavors, their machines are compatible with many other brands’ flavorings.

Final thoughts on Why Does Sparkling Water Taste Bad?

Improving the Taste of Sparkling Water

While the question ‘why does sparkling water taste bad’ is subjective and varies from person to person, the reasons generally revolve around the carbonation process and unfamiliarity with the taste.

However, a home soda maker offers an ideal solution. It allows you to control the carbonation level and experiment with different flavors, making your sparkling water experience more enjoyable.

So, for those who love sparkling water but can’t get past the taste, a home soda maker could be the answer to all your problems.

Written by:

Home Soda Maker